How far did the Congress of Vienna (1815) ignore the claims of nationality in Europe?
Representatives of Great Powers in Vienna: After the fall
of Napoleon in 1814, it was decided to hold a Congress of Vienna to settle the
affairs of Continent. Some of the sovereigns of Europe including the Tsar, the
King of Prussia, and the Austrian Emperor were present. Many prominent
statesmen also took part. Great Britain was represented by Lord Castlereagh,
the foreign Secretary and the Duke of Wellington. Tallerat was the representative
of France. Matternich, the leading minister of Austria, presided over the
Congress.
The aim of the Congress: The aim of the Congress was to
reward States which had opposed Napoleon and to penalize those which had
supported him. It wanted to strengthen the states near France. In case there
was a renewal of war by France, these states might check her. As far as possible,
the Congress tried to restore legitimate rulers to the thrones they had lost. Yet
the Congress did not aim at a complete restoration of pre-war Europe. It refused
to re-establish the republics of Venice and Genoa. It had no wish to restore the
Holy Roman Europe.
Distribution of Territories: Germany became a confederation
of independent states under the presidency of Austria, Russia got Central
Poland, some small Turkish territories and Finland. Prussia got Western Pomerania
part of Saxony and some Rhenish provinces. Austria lost Belgium but received Lombardy
and Venetia in Italy and the Illyrian provinces on the Adriatic Sea, Sweden
received Norway, England Received Malta, Heligoland, protectorate over the
Ionian islands, Ceylon, the Cape of Good Hope, and other colonial territories and
commercial advantages. She became the greatest colonial power in the world.
Restoration of the Old Order: After making the above settlement
of territories, the congress turned its attention to the work of resting pre-revolutionary
conditions. France was allowed to retain her monarchial frontiers. The old Bourbon
Monarchy was restored. Louis XVIII became the King of France. Holland and Belgium
were united into one kingdom. Switzerland was given back her independence. German
Confederation took the place of the old Holy Roman Empire. Spain was placed
under the rule of her Bourbon King. Italy under the control of Austria was
partitioned into a number of small states. The kingdom of Piedmont Sardinia was
strengthened.
Criticism or Defects of the Congress of Vienna: The
arrangements made at Vienna have been very much criticized. The wishes of
Europe were not taken into consideration. The people of Belgium disliked the Dutch
connection. Norwegians resented being ruled by Sweden. Poles chafed against Russian
rule. Germany and Italy were left in a divided condition. This was done against
the wishes of the more enlightened of their people. The Congress considered the
interests of sovereigns rather than those of people. European territories were
treated as private estates to be divided up at the will of their owners. Yet Napoleon
had been overthrown by the people of Europe.
Criticizing the arrangements made at Vienna, Southgate
says: ‘Since the Congress disregarded national feeling, which during the
nineteenth century proved to be more powerful than royal interest, the settlement
failed to be permanent. Many of the Vienna decisions were reversed or modified before
the end of the nineteenth century’.
The real charge against the Congress of Vienna is that it ignored
the challenge of the French Revolution. It failed to see the new forces of
democracy and nationality. Hazen writes: ‘The Congress of Vienna was a congress
of aristocrats to whom the ideas of nationality and democracy as proclaimed by
the French Revolution were incomprehensive or loathsome. The rulers arranged
Europe according to their own desires, disposing off it as it were their own
personal property, ignoring the sentiment of nationality, been so wonderfully
aroused, they were indifferent to the wishes of the people. Thiers could be settlement
because they ignored the factors that alone would make the settlement permanent’.
No comments:
Post a Comment