There
was a swing away from freedom of the press to control and the imposition of restrictions
on the press by the government during the period when Nehru’s daughter Mrs.
Indira Gandhi became prime minister.
While
Nehru was a liberal and believed in freedom of the press, Mrs. Indira Gandhi
was authoritarian and believed in curbing of the press. Unlike Nehru who
tolerated criticism, she felt that the press was too critical of her policies
and sought to chain the press.
During
her regime, she expected that the press should blindly support her government
without questioning her ability to deliver the goods. It should be “committed”
to her party and her government and act as its spokesman. Various threats were
held out by Government and steps proposed to curb that section of the press,
which was thought to be the most independent. A propaganda barrage was mounted
against the press, which appeared to be not easily amenable to the
wishes of the Government.
In
1971, the government led by Mrs. Gandhi made its first attempt to control the
press when her own ministry of Information and Broadcasting prepared a draft
scheme to “diffuse” the monopoly press, i.e., ownership of newspapers with a
circulation of more than 15,000.
In
fact, in the Parliament she had gone to the extent of declaring that freedom of
the press did not mean going against the national policy of the country.
Mrs.
Gandhi got the opportunity to curb the press when war was declared with
Pakistan in 1971.
On December 4th
the Defense
and Internal Security of India Act was signed into law. This Act imposed upon
the press restrictions similar to those of the Newspapers Incitement to
Offences Act of 1908, the Indian Press Act of 1910, the Indian Press Ordinance
of 1930 and the Indian Press (Emergency Press) Act of 1931: it prohibited the
printing or publishing of any newspaper, book or other document detrimental to the
defense and security of India; it provided for the demand of security from any newspaper
or publisher or the forfeiture of security already given; it empowered the Government
to confiscate copies of any printed matter which might be inflammatory and to
close down the presses; and it empowered the state and local Governments to impose
censorship.
Mrs.
Gandhi’s antipathy to the press continued and got further intensified after the
declaration of internal emergency on June 26, 1975. The emergency lasted for 19
months and this period is considered to be the darkest period in the post-independence
history of the freedom of the press.
The
same day, under her direction, the Government issued the “Central Censorship
Order” and “Guidelines
for the Press in the present Emergency”. It was for the first time in post-independence
India, stringent pre-censorship, which was something unknown and alien to the
people of free India, was imposed on the press.
The
Central Censorship Order, addressed to all printers, publishers and editors,
prohibited the publication of news, comments, rumours, or other reports
relating to actions taken by the Government in any newspaper, periodical or
other documents without their first being submitted for scrutiny to an authorized
officer of the Government. The Chief Censor of the Government was given total responsibility
of supervising and directing the entire censorship operation throughout the
country.
On
February 11, 1976, with the approval of the legislature, Mrs. Gandhi’s Government
presented journalists with the Prevention of Publication of Objectionable Matters
Act of 1976. Included in it were all the provisions of suppression contained in
the 1908, 1910, 1930, 1931, 1932 and 1951 Acts.
The
provisions of this act extending to the entire territory of India were made
effective retroactive to December 8, 1975.The Act empowered the central
Government or the competent authority (officers above a certain rank in the
central and state Governments and union territories) to prohibit publications
detrimental to the sovereignty and integrity of India, friendly relations
with foreign countries, public order, decency, morality or publications inciting
the breaking of law.
It
also empowered competent authority to serve warning, to demand security or
declare security forfeit, or to demand further security from publishers and
printers suspected of printing Objectionable Matters. It empowered the central
Government or competent authority to shut down or confiscate printing presses for
failure to furnish the required deposits, to confiscate objectionable literature
and to impose jail terms and fines for violations.
Customs
officers were given authority to confiscate objectionable materials and state
police officers to seize unauthorized newspapers and news-sheets. Metropolitan
magistrates, chief judicial magistrates and first class magistrates were
authorized to issue warrants to enter establishments
for the confiscation of printing presses and to seize objectionable newspapers
and news-sheets.
In
a report presented before Parliament, it was revealed that during the emergency
Mrs. Gandhi ruthlessly distorted and manipulated the country press, radio and television
media.
There
were two Commissions set up by the Government after Emergency to enquire into
excesses related to the press.
According
to the Das Commission Report, 253 journalists were arrested during the state of Emergency.
Fifty-one journalists and cameramen were deprived of accreditation, seven
foreign correspondents were expelled from the country and twenty-nine foreign correspondents
were banned from entering India. The commission further charged that Mrs.
Gandhi used the press to distort the news.
The
Shah Commission’s findings charged Mrs. Gandhi’s Government with the following:-
• The Government resorted to cutting off the
electricity of newspaper offices on June 26, the day after the emergency was
proclaimed in order to buy time to set up the apparatus of the censorship.
Three days later when the censorship machinery was set up, the power supply was
resumed.
• The Indian Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting designated newspapers as either hostile, friendly or neutral and
issued instructions to withhold or reduce advertisements from hostile and
neutral newspapers and to increase advertisements in friendly newspapers.
• The Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting ordered a study of the newspapers over the six month period
preceding the emergency in order to determine each newspaper’s attitude to
Government and to penalize it accordingly.
With
the exception of the few journalists and newspapers, most of the Indian press yielded
to the Government’s wishes. The Indian press during the Emergency, described by
David Loshak as “India’s Sterile Press” filled with the insipid handouts of the
Ministry of Information. Every spark of intellectual independence had been snuffed
out and what was reported appeared to be nothing more than Government propaganda.
There
is a clear contrast between Nehru and Indira Gandhi’s attitude to the press, which
was the result of the difference between the personality and values of these
two prime ministers.
While
Nehru welcomed criticism of his government by the press, Indira Gandhi hated
criticism of her government. Nehru’s period was characterized by cooperation
and understanding between the government and the press, but Indira Gandhi’s
period was characterized by hostility and confrontation between government and
the press.
Nehru
believed that the press should express the wishes and grievances of the people
but Mrs. Gandhi believed that the press should be the spokesman of the government.
Durga Das, head of India News and Features Alliance, has rightly observed her
attitude towards the press:“Mrs. Gandhi does not accept the basic philosophy of
a newspaper that it has to convey the people’s problems, not the government
view, that a columnist must carry the voice of dissent in the corridors of power.
It is the best safety valve a government has. Her father understood that”.
The
emergency was lifted in March 1977 and in the subsequent elections Mrs. Gandhi lost
power and the JANATA Party under the Prime Ministership of Morarji Desai came
into the power. This marked the swing from control of the press back to freedom
of the press and removal of all restrictions upon it. While Mrs. Gandhi was authoritarian,
Morarji Desai was liberal in personality and values. The Press began to act with
great vigour almost as a rebound after the Emergency was lifted. In an interview
following assumption of the Prime Minister’s office, Desai said: “Fundamental
rights should never be touched, whether there is an emergency or not.
They
must be maintained under the constitution.”
On
April 18, within one month of taking the reins of the government, Desai
obtained the approval of both Houses of Parliament and the signature of the
President for repeal of the Prevention of Publication of the objectionable Matter
Act of 1976, and approving the Parliamentary Proceedings (Protection of
Publication) Act of 1977.
Freedom
of the press thus returned to India, and the status of the press was restored
to that of the pre-emergency era. In speeches and in actions, Desai
demonstrated his unwavering support for maintaining
a free press and this put him in favour with journalists and readers alike. He
appointed L.K. Advani as his Minister for Information and Broadcasting. Like many
other ministers in Desai’s new Government, Advani had served a term in jail during
the emergency; but more importantly, he was a journalist, having served as a Joint
Editor of Organizer from 1960 to 1967. During the first week of his appointment,
Advani declared his intention to repeal the legislation curbing the press.
The
JANATA Party lost power in the elections held in December 1979. Since January
1980, with the change of Government, the attitude of the Government of India
toward the press reverted back to one of antipathy and confrontation. There was
a swing towards restricting freedom of the press again when Mrs. Gandhi
returned to power. Many of the new State Governments which came to power in the
middle of 1980 showed active hostility to the press. Instances of threats to
the free functioning of the press were not uncommon. Indira Gandhi herself
indicated more than once her dislike of the manner in which what was called the
National Press operated.
On
January 15, the day after taking office, Mrs. Gandhi cautioned the press to be
more objective and
to exercise self restraint. She said that there would not be a censorship as
long as the press behaved responsibly. In a Press Conference held in
September13, 1979, she said: “Censorship was a special remedy for a very
severe, acute disease. We don’t think that particular disease will hit the
country again. Nor do we want to give the same medicine
Indira
Gandhi’s son, Rajiv Gandhi, became Prime Minister after the assassination of his
mother in 1984. He came to power on the crest of a wave of sympathy after his mother’s
death and so he had a smooth relationship with the public and the press for the
first few years. The press started becoming critical of his government
afterwards and so he got the Defamation Bill, 1988, passed in Lok Sabha,
thereby making an attempt to suppress the press. This was an indication of a
swing from freedom of the press in the first three years to restriction of this
freedom in the last two years of his rule. The mounting pressure of the public
and the press forced the government to withdraw
the Bill without referring it to the Rajya Sabha. However, it showed that like his
mother, Rajiv Gandhi could not tolerate criticism of his government and was willing
to curtail the freedom of the press.
Conclusion
It
is evident from the history of freedom of the press during the past two
centuries from its inception in the 1780s to 1980s that the Government of India
took measures both during the pre and post-independence period to curtail the
freedom of the press.
There
were more Governor Generals and Viceroys who passed laws imposing restrictions
on the press than those who relaxed such restrictions. After independence also,
laws continued to be passed imposing restrictions on the press. There was always
confrontation between the government and the press with the press waging a
battle to preserve its freedom against the powers of the government. It is a
tribute to the resilience of the press in the face of such heavy odds that it
continued to grow in numbers as well as influence throughout this period. This
is because the press from the beginning had the sanction of public opinion and
the gradually developing democratic tradition in India.
Watch the video by clicking the link: Press During Emergency